• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • New? Start Here!

RunToTheFinish

Online Running Coach for All Paces, All Ages

  • Training
    • Beginner Half Marathon Training
    • Sub Two Half Marathon Training
    • Marathon Training
    • New Runner Tips
    • Low Heart Rate Training
    • Group Run Coaching
    • Nutrition for Runners
  • Running Injuries
  • Gear Reviews
  • Work Together
    • Online Run Coaching
    • 1-1 Coaching
    • Brand Partnerships
  • Shop
    • Book
    • Book Tour
    • IT Band Solution
    • LHR Training Plans
  • Blog

Galloway Vs Hanson: Which Marathon Training Plan is Right For You?

113shares

Have you ever wondered the difference between all the marathon training plans out there? How do you begin to pick a marathon training plan? Will a free marathon plan off the internet do the trick?

FIRST, Galloway Method, Hal Higdon training or this crazy Low Heart Rate thing that I’ve been rambling about for years now?

I’ve broken down details on each training method with feedback from fellow runners and coaches to give you not only what the plan is, but exactly how it worked for a variety of runners.Exploring the Differences between Popular Marathon Training Plans - click to see what's right for youSince plans can run from low mileage with high intensity to high mileage with low intensity and a smattering of things in between, it’s confusing to understand what is really the best way to train!

My philosophy is that no “best way” exists, it’s about finding the program that WORKS for you and hopefully the following deep dives will help you make the best decision when picking a marathon training plan.

Click on any of the plan names below to see full details:

FIRST method — 3 runs per week
Hanson method — Shorter long runs, all fast
Galloway method — Run-walk method
LHR method  – Focus on building base and maintaining hormonal balance, fat burning
CrossFit Endurance  – Using CrossFit as base with much less running

Hal Higdon Marathon Training

I did not do a separate post for the Hal Higdon marathon plan or McMillan running plans, which would fall in to your classical training plan program. They follow a very similar patter, which you’ve likely seen:

  • 5 runs per week
  • a long run up to 22 miles
  • one speed workout
  • limited cross training designed in the plan

There are tons of these marathon plans and they absolutely work. I focused the in depth additional reviews on other plans that you may have seen less to help understand the differences in training methods and why they might work for some people and not others.

For example,  my friend Corey thrives on the hard fast 16 miler, while I need the chill of LHR training to make it through months of long runs.

You can assume that 90% of the free training plans you find online are based upon that classical style of marathon training. One that I frequently recommend is from Train Like a Mother, though next March I’ll be pointing you to my new book!!

If there is another method you are curious about be sure to leave a comment! The final well-known plan not explored here is Pfitzinger’s Advanced Marathon plan, as it’s more advanced than I think most runners here need.

Still not sure what plan is right for you? In my small personalized 1-1 coaching, I can help you decide and create a personalized plan to get you to the finish line! Click here for more information.

how to pick a marathon training program

What is the Best Marathon Plan?

Hopefully an inside look at each method will help you select a plan not just to survive, but thrive during marathon training!

For all of the training methods a few key factors should be considered when deciding which one is right for your body, your training and your goals…just because it works for your running partner or even your coach doesn’t meant it’s right for you.

Here are the biggest factors to consider when you choose.

#1 Current Running Ability

If you’re a newer runner, returning from injury or have recurring injuries then selecting a high intensity plan may be a recipe for disaster. These plans require dedication to proper running form, recovery and nutrition.

#2 Training Timeline

Longer training plans (18-24 weeks) allow your body to gradually adjust to the higher volume of miles, but they also require extended mental and physical commitment.

  • Advanced runners may find they peak too quickly on a longer training cycle and new runners can burn out.
  • If selecting a longer plan, try having smaller goal races like a half marathon or 10K sprinkled throughout.
Considering a marathon? A detailed breakdown of the top training plan methods #runchat via @runtothefinish Click To Tweet

#3 Preferred Intensity

Does the thought of a track workout make you cringe or get your inner warrior fired up? The use of speed workouts is going to appear in every plan, but the intensity level and repetition will vary, so look for the one that matches your preferred method of training.

#4 Running Frequency

Depending upon the other types of training you’d like to incorporate and your injury history this could be one of the biggest factors in plan selection.

  • If you don’t like running 5 days a week, don’t feel pressured in to a training plan that requires it.
  • If you love doing CrossFit as a runner or Zumba to spice things up, make sure your plan involves adequate cross training days.
  • Many advanced training plans can have up to 6 days of running each week with very little cross training and that’s great if it excites you!
  • Or you can scrap all that and go to a 10 day training cycle like Bart Yasso

#5 Long Run Preference

The crux of most marathon training plans is completing the weekly long run.

Each plan has a different logic behind the number and distance of long runs, reviewing that is important, but it’s also crucial to know what will help you mentally feel prepared.

Many runners enjoy doing multiple 20 mile runs because it gives them the confidence they need to cross the finish line, while others simply feel burdened by that schedule.

online running coach

It’s also important to realize that one plan my work for many years and then suddenly you find you’ve plateaued or are injured or simply can’t keep it up as life changes.

That’s ok and normal! Don’t be afraid to explore other options when trying to pick a marathon training plan.

Feel like you’ve got the right plan, then read more in the Road to a PR Series:

Picking the right race to help hit your goal >>
Choosing your race pace goal >>
Creating your own training plan >>
Why you need a base building phase>>
Safely adding speed work >>
Why you need a peak week >>
How to  correctly taper for a race >>
Race day etiquette do’s and don’ts >>

How did you pick your current plan?

What matters most to you in a plan?

Other ways to connect with Amanda
Instagram Daily Fun: RunToTheFinish

Facebook Community Chatter: RunToTheFinishRunning_motivation_thumb

Sign Up to Receive a Weekly Newsletter with Top Running Tips

 

113shares

Posted by amanda Categories: Marathon, marathon training, running coach, training plan

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Coach Henness says

    September 4, 2016 at 6:25 pm

    Or better yet, a custom training plan with a certified running coach! ;-)

    • Susie @ SuzLyfe says

      September 5, 2016 at 5:57 am

      PREACH

  2. Noelle Eichenberger says

    September 4, 2016 at 7:34 pm

    Hal Higdon’s plan? That’s another one that is pretty popular…. I’m excited to read these posts!

  3. Diana Fitts says

    September 5, 2016 at 2:05 pm

    I’m excited to read your take on these training plans! I have used the FIRST program and one from Competitor. My experiences were so different with each that it inspired me to write my most recent book on running goals. Choosing the right plan is essential to the overall success of the race and happiness with the experience.
    Diana
    betterthanalive.com

  4. Laura @ This Runner's Recipes says

    September 6, 2016 at 12:04 pm

    I’m excited to read your take on plans! While Hansons didn’t work for me, their philosophy works really well for other runners I know. Although I advocate custom plans, I know that’s not a realistic option for every runner, so it’s good to be informed and have a coach’s’ opinion of the generalized plans out there.

  5. Jessica says

    September 25, 2016 at 1:51 am

    Hal Higdon??

    • Traci Havlik says

      August 16, 2017 at 2:19 pm

      Love Hal’s Plans!

  6. Bethany says

    July 21, 2019 at 3:31 pm

    Thanks for writing such a detailed and objective comparison. I’m in the camp of a personalized coach beats all, but there are such great resources out there for athletes who want to go the self-coached route, too.

    Bethany
    https://bethanyrutledge.com

  7. chloe says

    July 25, 2019 at 2:31 am

    i had to chime in on this one! i’m currently training with Coached (coached.fitness – it’s Singapore-based, set up by a Kiwi) , their training plans are solely heart-rate/ time based – you can choose to track your distance as well with a GPS watch of course, but i’ve decided after a long hard debate with myself that it’d probably do me more harm than good so i’ve just gone off time and HR for almost a year now.

    basically, you go for a LT test (or use the MAF formula and/ or do your own sort of trial) to get your heart rate zones. their zones are slightly different from the usual HR-zone training plans, and the training philosophy is on the low intensity/ high mileage end of the spectrum.

    have been enjoying it loads, though like the MAF method, slowing down at first was H A R D. but i’m glad i stuck with it, i enjoy training so much more now (more than racing, ha) and i’ve also gotten faster at a lower heart rate. i got burnt out trying a couple of other online plans, including the train like a mother one – but it was probably my fault for not slowing down enough during my long runs. i think if you want to self-coach, you really have to have the discipline to slow down and admit to yourself that what you thought was your conversational pace… is not really your conversational pace after all!

    my favourite distance is also the half-marathon. :)

    • amanda says

      July 25, 2019 at 2:42 pm

      agree, self coaching requires a ton of discipline. Especially with LHR because it can feel counter intuitive, but it works!

  8. bottam says

    July 28, 2019 at 10:59 pm

    I am an office worker, sometimes busy with work and have little time to practice.
    I often spend time jogging for myself in the early morning or late afternoon after returning home from work. Jogging helps my health improve a lot.
    The knowledge you share makes the start-up and my exercises more complete.
    Thank you very much
    Important & Thanks

Primary Sidebar

Filter by Category
  • Select a Category
  • 10 miler
  • 10K
  • 13.1 marathon series
  • 15K
  • 30 Day Challenge
  • 5k
  • About ME
  • Abs
  • Active Travel
  • alaska
  • Amanda Brooks
  • Arizona
  • Asics
  • Austin
  • Baltimore
  • barefoot running
  • beauty
  • Biking
  • birthday
  • bloggers
  • blogging tips
  • body fat
  • body image
  • body weight exercises
  • book reviews
  • Boston Marathon
  • breakfast
  • California
  • Camping
  • Canada
  • Caribbean
  • chicago
  • ChiRunning
  • Clean Eating
  • cold weather training
  • colorado
  • compression
  • Costa Rica
  • Crockpot
  • cross training
  • CrossFit
  • dairy free
  • dessert
  • egg free
  • electrolytes
  • emotional health
  • Europe
  • family
  • Fit Together
  • fitness gear
  • Fitness Tracker
  • fitness vacation
  • florida
  • foam roller
  • food sensitivity
  • Fort Lauderdale
  • France
  • Funny Running
  • Gift Guide
  • Gluten Free
  • GPS Watch
  • Green Smoothie
  • Guides and Tips
  • habits
  • Half Marathon
  • Hawaii
  • HBBC
  • health coach
  • healthy eating
  • Healthy Home
  • Healthy lifestyle
  • Heart Rate Training
  • HIIT workout
  • hiking
  • hiking
  • Hip Strength
  • Hoka One One
  • Holistic Health
  • Hormones
  • hydration
  • Iceland
  • injury
  • inspiration
  • instagram
  • Ireland
  • IT Band
  • IT Band Recovery
  • Jerusalem
  • key west
  • knee injury
  • Kona
  • Love
  • low heart rate training
  • Maffetone
  • main dish
  • Marathon
  • marathon training
  • marriage
  • meal planning
  • Meditation
  • Memphis
  • mental marathon training
  • Mexico
  • Miami
  • Motivation
  • New York City
  • New York City Marathon
  • New York City Marathon Training
  • NYC marathon
  • Oregon
  • Orlando
  • Palm Beach
  • Philadelphia Marathon
  • physical therapy
  • podcasts
  • Prague
  • Product Review
  • Race
  • race costume
  • race medal
  • race photo
  • race report
  • Ragnar
  • Recipe
  • recovery
  • recovery meal
  • relaxation
  • relay race
  • resolution run
  • review
  • Rock N Roll
  • run club
  • Runner's World
  • running accessories
  • running books
  • running coach
  • running form
  • running fuel
  • running gear
  • Running Group
  • running motivation
  • running music
  • Running Shoes
  • safety
  • salads
  • san diego
  • Saucony
  • Seattle
  • skin care
  • Soup
  • South Beach
  • South Carolina
  • South Florida
  • speed work
  • sports nutrition
  • Stand Up Paddle Boarding
  • Steamboat Springs
  • Strength Training
  • stretching
  • sugar reduction
  • Thanksgiving
  • trail running
  • Training Group
  • training plan
  • travel
  • travel running
  • treadmill
  • treadmill workout
  • triathlon
  • ultrarunning
  • vegan
  • Vegas
  • vegatarian
  • vegetable
  • virtual run
  • wedding
  • weight loss
  • winter
  • women's running
  • workout
  • workout motivation
  • workout schedule
  • Yoga

5 Secrets to Improve Your RUn

Start Making Quick Progress on Your Goals (I swear it's easy) no matter your current fitness level. The tips I share with the runners I coach.

Recent Posts

  • How Quickly Do You Lose Fitness: Bounce Back from Missed Runs
  • The Year That Almost Wasn’t
  • Top 10 Men’s Running Pants | Lightweight to Winter Tights
  • Snowshoeing for Beginners
  • Best Fitness Books : What’s Worth Actually Reading

Must Have Gear

Comparing GPS Watches

Best HR Monitor for Running

Best Foam Rollers

Best Running Books

Running Jackets for Every Condition

fitness partners

Please note that affiliate links {such as Amazon} may pop up on RTTF from time to time. They do not cost you anything to use, but are a huge help to support the ongoing content creation process. Click here to do your shopping!

Welcome!!

Hello runners! I’m Amanda Brooks, a certified personal trainer and running coach. I’ve been coaching over a decade and distance running since 2002. My philosophy is that running isn’t about your pace or the distance or your body. It’s about showing up for yourself, loving the process and doing it injury free!

 

online running coach

Footer

Get the Free 5 Day Better Runner Challenge

Start Making Quick Progress on Your Goals (I swear it's easy)

About Amanda Brooks

Amanda Brooks is a Certified Running Coach, Certified Personal Trainer and long time distance runner with a passion for every facet of running, which leads her to do more reading, research and running than necessary. Find all the tips, tricks and tools you need from this running coach for your best injury free running. Read More…

Popular Posts on RunToTheFinish

  • Piriformis Syndrome Exercises: Alleviating a Pain in the Butt
  • Suunto vs Garmin: Which GPS Watch Is Better for You
  • 17 Funniest Running Memes – Which One’s Do You Relate To?
  • T25, P90X3, PiYo – Can it Improve Your Running? Complete Comparison
  • Brooks vs Asics: What’s the Difference in Running Brands

runtothefinish

Amanda Brooks : Run Coach
A NEW PLAN DOESN’T FIX EVERYTHING. You might alr A NEW PLAN DOESN’T FIX EVERYTHING. You might already know what’s best for you, but aren’t doing it consistently. That’s the only way we really make changes.
.
A PLAN can help, but I often don’t think that’s step one to making lasting change.
//
HABITS AND ROUTINES✴️
-Eliminate the need to make decisions.
-Which reduces brain fatigue.
-Which increases your chance of success.
//
TINY HABITS✴️
This is the smallest step you can take towards your goal. Often so small it seems insignificant, but is easy to make it a habit.
🌟
That leads you to another tiny habit, then another and suddenly it’s just your lifestyle.
👆👆👆
When people ask how I easily kept off 35lbs for over 15 years, while enjoying pizza, taking rest days and not obsessing about food.
👇👇👇👇
When people ask how I stay motivated to run year round and rarely race. Tiny habits.
//
Day one isn’t eat perfect or run for an hour.
.
Day one IS drink a glass of water when I wake up. Put on my running clothes.
.
Day 30 is then more like after I drink my glass of water, I do 5 push ups. After I put on my running clothes, I do a 5 minute warm up.
//
SLOW PROGRESS IS BETTER THAN NO PROGRESS, it builds momentum and is sustainable.
❔❔❔
Have you ever practiced creating tiny habits???
1️⃣ WORD TO DESCRIBE YOUR RUNNING THIS YEAR? M 1️⃣ WORD TO DESCRIBE YOUR RUNNING THIS YEAR?
Mine... satisfying.
😊
1900 miles blows away previous years.
.
(swipe to see...because yes I love tracking.) Unfortunately I’m not positive what it was 2001-2007 because I wrote it on calendars.
//
SATISFYING
🥰I needed the long miles early on to process my business being thrown for a loop. Bye bye book tour and partnerships.
😊I needed it after that to get away from the news and pretend I wasn’t spending all day alone. Then as my business shifted again to keep ideas flowing.
🌲I loved the time outside to think, get lost in a comedy podcast or audiobook. Otherwise I’m at home working!
🤩Without a single race, I still checked a big goal off my list of running an ultra distance (solo was very interesting!).
//
I’ve seen some posts that make it seem like we’re wrong for talking about what we achieved this year.
.
It was a HARD FCKIN year for everyone, but guess what lots of years are. And not every year is great even without a pandemic.
//
For all the lows this year, I also worked my ass off to make some really good things happen. And I’m extra proud of that.
//
So let’s hear your word for fitness in 2020??
⬇️
Hard, easy, strong, powerful, consistent, cleansing, relaxing, nature, grace, grit, grind, triumph, building...
HAIR EMOJI POLL!!! Seriously hair...it’s a lot r HAIR EMOJI POLL!!! Seriously hair...it’s a lot right?! Figuring out what to do with it, color it don’t color it, keep it healthy, breakage from ponytails, long, short. And yet a good hair day😃 🔥 🌟
//
POLL:
🥰Love your hair
🤪Frustrated with your hair
1️⃣Natural curls
2️⃣Stick straight
👇👇👇
Curly friends: share your favorite tips!!
Long hair friends: what helps you keep it healthy?
👆👆👆
//
At 7 I could sit in my hair it was so long.
At 10 we started perms.
At 16 I had a full mane of hair I loved.
At 20 I learned I have naturally curly hair 😂after years of perms as a kid.
At 25 I was going blonde blonde blonde.
At 29 I began losing hair and it got so brittle I had to chop it off, due to the hormone issues.😭
At 35 my hair started to recover (as did my body), but never like that mane I loved as a teen.
At 39 I got my first curly haircut! I’m still figuring it out, but was amazed at how it looked.
//
I don’t wear much make up, but I do admit to really caring about my hair and it was a tough time when it felt so unhealthy.
//
I’m still struggling to figure out this new curly style 😂but keep hearing from other curly girls ya just gotta stick it out. So we’ll see.
.
.
#curlygirlmethod #hairtalk
ARE YOU REALLY GOING TO RUN? Why don’t you just ARE YOU REALLY GOING TO RUN? Why don’t you just enjoy a day off? Don’t you feel guilty about the time apart?
//
Yes.
It makes me happy.
No, if I’m happy our time together is better.
👇👇👇
MY VIEW IS THIS...
❌If you aren’t working out because of food guilt
❌If you aren’t missing big moments because you must workout
✅If you enjoy it and it improves your day
✅THEN GO FORTH and don’t let anyone make you feel guilty for improving your mental and physical health.
//
❓Do you have guilt or get guilted about workouts for n holidays?❓
//
This has been my lifestyle so long that our families just know to expect that I’m gonna sweat. And of course, I’m lucky David wants this lifestyle too.
.
BUTTTTT I remember those first trips to David’s family, where it really threw them for a loop. They still find it weird, but I sneak out before everyone gets up or have gotten them to do family things like the rec center.
//
My best advice when asked has always been to try and calmly explain why it matters to you and then just go. They get over it or used to it.
🎁 🎄🕎
TAKE ANOTHER LITTLE PIZZA MY HEART 😂a reminder TAKE ANOTHER LITTLE PIZZA MY HEART 😂a reminder this holiday season that we all need to be loved differently...and pizza transcends all.
//
🍕Do you have a favorite local pizza place?🍕🍕
.
Yes, I knead to know for when we can travel again.
.
Here we fell in love in love with @saucyspizza and I wouldn’t be sad if I got it as a gift 😆
.
.
.
.
#pizzamemes #eatlocal #denvercolorado #ilovepizza #lovememes #pizzagram #digiorno #papajohns #foodisfuel #longrun #womenwhoeat #carbsarelife
Follow on Instagram
Website written, managed and maintained by Amanda Brooks, a certified running coach and personal trainer. Any advice should be taken as general information and not a personalized plan. All opinions, tips and reviews are based upon her personal life experience and the experiences of those she has coached. View our full privacy and review policy.

Copyright © 2021 RunToTheFinish

Copyright © 2021 · RunToTheFinish V2 on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in